With businesses now deploying artificial intelligence tools to do everything from translating speeches to building language learning models for large legal firms, many employees are starting to worry that they may soon be out of a job.
However, Noah Smith, author of the popular Noahpinion website, argued in an article that people shouldn’t worry about their jobs being automated just yet.
The common perception of automation is that it will drive humans out of the workforce—one day you are doing some valuable work, tomorrow you are on welfare,” Smith wrote. However, this is not the case! We have been deploying automation technology for centuries, and as of 2023, almost everyone who wants to work will still have a job."
What does automation mean?
In his article, Smith looked at several studies on job automation over the years by researchers from Citibank to PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Smith points out that in these studies, the term "automation" is never clearly defined, but together they all illustrate varying degrees of "substitution" assumptions. In some cases, like "You'll get new tools that let you automate boring parts of your job, allowing you to be promoted to a more valuable position," there will even be new benefits.
This means it’s difficult to draw sweeping conclusions about what automation will mean for any particular individual.
Another problem Smith points out is that these studies do not address how the labor market as a whole will change. He believes that "if one job is destroyed by automation and two other higher-paying jobs are created, the worker is the clear winner." However, research on this topic seems to focus only on automation, which may indicate that workers are The loser in this situation, even if that's not the case.
Assessing “replacement” is often subjective
Smith also pointed out that previous studies have used too much subjectivity when assessing the risk of a job being replaced.
In a study by Frey and Osborne (2013), the researchers noted that they "subjectively hand-labeled" jobs from a database developed by the U.S. Department of Labor if they were "automatable" , then score 1 point, if not, score 0 points.
The researchers also noted that they focused on only a small subset of the jobs in the database "for which we have high confidence in their computerized labels" to further reduce the risk of "subjective bias affecting our analyses."
The good news is that research methods have improved since then, Smith said.
A Goldman Sachs study published earlier this month assessed the impact of artificial intelligence on automation by looking at jobs as a sum of tasks described in government databases, rather than as a monolithic entity.
Goldman Sachs researchers also recognized that when only some tasks are automated, "automation often serves a complementary role rather than displacing workers," Smith noted.
Additionally, the study supports the idea that automation doesn’t always mean layoffs, noting that “technology can replace some tasks, but it can also make us more efficient at performing others and create New tasks and new jobs.”
However, when Forbes reported this study, the headline was "Goldman Sachs predicts artificial intelligence will eliminate or reduce 300 million jobs."
Smith writes, "Many people are so used to the 'robots taking our jobs' narrative that they report every outcome they see through a distorted lens.'"
The above is the detailed content of Why humans shouldn't fear being replaced by AI automation. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

HiddenLayer's groundbreaking research exposes a critical vulnerability in leading Large Language Models (LLMs). Their findings reveal a universal bypass technique, dubbed "Policy Puppetry," capable of circumventing nearly all major LLMs' s

The push for environmental responsibility and waste reduction is fundamentally altering how businesses operate. This transformation affects product development, manufacturing processes, customer relations, partner selection, and the adoption of new

The recent restrictions on advanced AI hardware highlight the escalating geopolitical competition for AI dominance, exposing China's reliance on foreign semiconductor technology. In 2024, China imported a massive $385 billion worth of semiconductor

The potential forced divestiture of Chrome from Google has ignited intense debate within the tech industry. The prospect of OpenAI acquiring the leading browser, boasting a 65% global market share, raises significant questions about the future of th

Retail media's growth is slowing, despite outpacing overall advertising growth. This maturation phase presents challenges, including ecosystem fragmentation, rising costs, measurement issues, and integration complexities. However, artificial intell

An old radio crackles with static amidst a collection of flickering and inert screens. This precarious pile of electronics, easily destabilized, forms the core of "The E-Waste Land," one of six installations in the immersive exhibition, &qu

Google Cloud's Next 2025: A Focus on Infrastructure, Connectivity, and AI Google Cloud's Next 2025 conference showcased numerous advancements, too many to fully detail here. For in-depth analyses of specific announcements, refer to articles by my

This week in AI and XR: A wave of AI-powered creativity is sweeping through media and entertainment, from music generation to film production. Let's dive into the headlines. AI-Generated Content's Growing Impact: Technology consultant Shelly Palme


Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap
Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Article

Hot Tools

SAP NetWeaver Server Adapter for Eclipse
Integrate Eclipse with SAP NetWeaver application server.

Atom editor mac version download
The most popular open source editor

EditPlus Chinese cracked version
Small size, syntax highlighting, does not support code prompt function

SublimeText3 English version
Recommended: Win version, supports code prompts!

MantisBT
Mantis is an easy-to-deploy web-based defect tracking tool designed to aid in product defect tracking. It requires PHP, MySQL and a web server. Check out our demo and hosting services.
