search
HomeTechnology peripheralsAINature's new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

​This article is reprinted with the authorization of AI New Media Qubit (public account ID: QbitAI). Please contact the source for reprinting.

Facing ChatGPT, Nature finally couldn’t sit still.

This week, the fate of this authoritative academic publishing organization has been clarified regarding a series of issues such as ChatGPT’s ghostwriting of academic articles and being listed as an author.

Specifically, Nature lists two principles:

(1) Any large language model tool (such as ChatGPT) cannot become the author of the paper;
(2) If relevant tools have been used in the creation of the paper, the author should clearly state in the "Methods" or "Acknowledgments" or appropriate section.

The above requirements have now been added to the author submission guidelines.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

#In recent times, ChatGPT has become more and more involved in the academic and research circles.

In a paper on the anti-aging application of rapamycin in December last year, ChatGPT was listed as a work, causing controversy in the industry. In addition to this article, there are many studies listing ChatGPT as the author.

Nature has also noticed this situation. A survey they conducted in December showed that 20% of the 293 professors interviewed had discovered or witnessed students using ChatGPT to complete assignments or papers. More people are worried about this.

This time, the statement issued by Nature is precisely hoping to characterize various disputes.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

Multiple papers have listed ChatGPT as the author

ChatGPT was launched by OpenAI at the end of November last year because its performance significantly surpassed previous large languages. Model (LLM) quickly became the No. 1 "Sky Monkey" at the end of the year and the beginning of the year.

In the fields of new media, film and television, software development, game interaction and other fields, ChatGPT is quickly used to assist production and improve efficiency.

Xueyan Circle is no exception.

According to Nature statistics, there are at least 4 papers using ChatGPT and listing it as an author.

One of the preprints was published on the medical preprint database medRxiv in December 2022. This paper studies the performance of ChatGPT on the United States Medical Licensing Examination. Although the research is about ChatGPT, ChatGPT is also listed in the author column.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

Another paper was published in the journal "Nurse Education Practice" on the pros and cons of open artificial intelligence platforms in nursing education. Likewise, ChatGPT is listed as an author:

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

The third paper comes from Insilico Medicine, an AI drug research and development company. It is about a new drug rapamycin and was published in "Oncoscience". Likewise, ChatGPT is listed as the author.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

The fourth article is a bit "old" and was published in June 2022. The topic discussed is-the ability of AI to generate papers. The AI ​​listed in the author column is not ChatGPT, but GPT-3, which was released earlier.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

Although the above research content is somewhat related to generative language models, for serious scientific research activities, use "research objects" to write papers and list them as authors Column, inevitably triggered controversy and doubts.

And even if AI is not listed as the author, the use of ChatGPT in academic and research circles is becoming more and more common.

As mentioned earlier, Alex Zhavoronkov, CEO of Insilico Medicine, an AI drug research and development company, revealed that his institution has published more than 80 papers generated by AI tools.

British professor Mike Sharples has been paying attention to the impact of generative AI on academic research. Not long ago, he personally demonstrated on Twitter how to use a large language model to generate an academic paper in 10 minutes. He described step by step how he used AI to generate a summary based on the title, which also triggered a lot of discussion.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

It is more common for students to use ChatGPT to help write papers, generate code, and complete assignments. Currently, educational institutions in some areas of the United States have banned the use of this tool.

Just last week, a student at Northern Michigan University relied on ChatGPT to write an essay with the highest score in the class.

Interestingly, the student was caught because the article he submitted was so logically coherent and well-structured that the instructor only learned the truth after questioning him.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author
##△ Northern Michigan University

It needs to be made clear that the above packet capture was just accidental , and more often than not, the generated content has made it difficult for scientists to distinguish between authenticity and fiction.

A previous article in Nature pointed out that after the release of ChatGPT, a research team at Northwestern University in Illinois was exploring whether scientists could recognize the abstracts of medical papers generated using this AI tool.

The results found that all AI-generated summaries passed the plagiarism detector, and during manual review, 32% of the AI-generated summaries were considered to be completed by real humans.

Identification tools are already being developed

The nature’s failure shows that they attach great importance to the problems caused by ChatGPT.

In the latest content, Nature stated that the academic and research circles are worried that students and researchers may use content generated by large-scale language models as text written by themselves. In addition to taking risks, the above process also Can produce unreliable research conclusions.

Especially for ChatGPT, the Nature team and many publishers and platforms believe that this tool cannot be responsible for the integrity and content of scientific papers.

One side evidence is that the technology media CNET has exposed in the past two days that 41 of the 77 pieces of content written by the platform's AI have errors. At present, the platform has corrected them and stated that it will suspend the production of content in this way. .

It is precisely based on concerns about the above situation that Nature has issued relevant regulations.

As for how to distinguish AI-generated content?

Nature said that currently the raw output of ChatGPT can be discovered through careful inspection, especially when it comes to specific scientific work, the content may contain the simplest errors and general boring wording. In addition, Nature also said that they are still developing related recognition technology.

It is worth mentioning that relevant identification tools have also been developed.

For example, OpenAI’s own GPT-2 Output Detector can more accurately identify AI-generated text by inputting more than 50 characters (tokens).

Another example is Edward Tian, ​​a Princeton student, who also made a related tool GPTZero.

Natures new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author

However, not all university professors and teachers have a negative attitude towards AI generation tools.

For example, Ethan Mollick, a professor at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, went the other way and required students to use ChatGPT to complete class assignments, believing that this was embracing emerging technology tools.

A worker at medRxiv, a paper publishing platform, also said that ChatGPT is not a new problem.

He believes that before, researchers have tried to sneak in the names of pets and fictional characters. Therefore, they believe that the core of the

problem is the need to continue to strengthen inspections.

Finally, have you used ChatGPT in your scientific research work?

The above is the detailed content of Nature's new rules: You can use ChatGPT to write papers, but not to be listed as an author. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Statement
This article is reproduced at:51CTO.COM. If there is any infringement, please contact admin@php.cn delete
Tesla's Robovan Was The Hidden Gem In 2024's Robotaxi TeaserTesla's Robovan Was The Hidden Gem In 2024's Robotaxi TeaserApr 22, 2025 am 11:48 AM

Since 2008, I've championed the shared-ride van—initially dubbed the "robotjitney," later the "vansit"—as the future of urban transportation. I foresee these vehicles as the 21st century's next-generation transit solution, surpas

Sam's Club Bets On AI To Eliminate Receipt Checks And Enhance RetailSam's Club Bets On AI To Eliminate Receipt Checks And Enhance RetailApr 22, 2025 am 11:29 AM

Revolutionizing the Checkout Experience Sam's Club's innovative "Just Go" system builds on its existing AI-powered "Scan & Go" technology, allowing members to scan purchases via the Sam's Club app during their shopping trip.

Nvidia's AI Omniverse Expands At GTC 2025Nvidia's AI Omniverse Expands At GTC 2025Apr 22, 2025 am 11:28 AM

Nvidia's Enhanced Predictability and New Product Lineup at GTC 2025 Nvidia, a key player in AI infrastructure, is focusing on increased predictability for its clients. This involves consistent product delivery, meeting performance expectations, and

Exploring the Capabilities of Google's Gemma 2 ModelsExploring the Capabilities of Google's Gemma 2 ModelsApr 22, 2025 am 11:26 AM

Google's Gemma 2: A Powerful, Efficient Language Model Google's Gemma family of language models, celebrated for efficiency and performance, has expanded with the arrival of Gemma 2. This latest release comprises two models: a 27-billion parameter ver

The Next Wave of GenAI: Perspectives with Dr. Kirk Borne - Analytics VidhyaThe Next Wave of GenAI: Perspectives with Dr. Kirk Borne - Analytics VidhyaApr 22, 2025 am 11:21 AM

This Leading with Data episode features Dr. Kirk Borne, a leading data scientist, astrophysicist, and TEDx speaker. A renowned expert in big data, AI, and machine learning, Dr. Borne offers invaluable insights into the current state and future traje

AI For Runners And Athletes: We're Making Excellent ProgressAI For Runners And Athletes: We're Making Excellent ProgressApr 22, 2025 am 11:12 AM

There were some very insightful perspectives in this speech—background information about engineering that showed us why artificial intelligence is so good at supporting people’s physical exercise. I will outline a core idea from each contributor’s perspective to demonstrate three design aspects that are an important part of our exploration of the application of artificial intelligence in sports. Edge devices and raw personal data This idea about artificial intelligence actually contains two components—one related to where we place large language models and the other is related to the differences between our human language and the language that our vital signs “express” when measured in real time. Alexander Amini knows a lot about running and tennis, but he still

Jamie Engstrom On Technology, Talent And Transformation At CaterpillarJamie Engstrom On Technology, Talent And Transformation At CaterpillarApr 22, 2025 am 11:10 AM

Caterpillar's Chief Information Officer and Senior Vice President of IT, Jamie Engstrom, leads a global team of over 2,200 IT professionals across 28 countries. With 26 years at Caterpillar, including four and a half years in her current role, Engst

New Google Photos Update Makes Any Photo Pop With Ultra HDR QualityNew Google Photos Update Makes Any Photo Pop With Ultra HDR QualityApr 22, 2025 am 11:09 AM

Google Photos' New Ultra HDR Tool: A Quick Guide Enhance your photos with Google Photos' new Ultra HDR tool, transforming standard images into vibrant, high-dynamic-range masterpieces. Ideal for social media, this tool boosts the impact of any photo,

See all articles

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress

Undresser.AI Undress

AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover

AI Clothes Remover

Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool

Undress AI Tool

Undress images for free

Clothoff.io

Clothoff.io

AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap

Video Face Swap

Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Tools

Atom editor mac version download

Atom editor mac version download

The most popular open source editor

SublimeText3 Linux new version

SublimeText3 Linux new version

SublimeText3 Linux latest version

mPDF

mPDF

mPDF is a PHP library that can generate PDF files from UTF-8 encoded HTML. The original author, Ian Back, wrote mPDF to output PDF files "on the fly" from his website and handle different languages. It is slower than original scripts like HTML2FPDF and produces larger files when using Unicode fonts, but supports CSS styles etc. and has a lot of enhancements. Supports almost all languages, including RTL (Arabic and Hebrew) and CJK (Chinese, Japanese and Korean). Supports nested block-level elements (such as P, DIV),

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

SecLists

SecLists

SecLists is the ultimate security tester's companion. It is a collection of various types of lists that are frequently used during security assessments, all in one place. SecLists helps make security testing more efficient and productive by conveniently providing all the lists a security tester might need. List types include usernames, passwords, URLs, fuzzing payloads, sensitive data patterns, web shells, and more. The tester can simply pull this repository onto a new test machine and he will have access to every type of list he needs.