Does SQL's WHERE Clause Guarantee Short-Circuit Evaluation?

SQL WHERE Clause: Short-Circuit Evaluation – Myth or Reality?

SQL's WHERE clause involves boolean expression evaluation. The question arises: does it employ short-circuiting, stopping evaluation once the outcome is certain? This impacts query optimization and performance significantly.

Short-Circuiting: Guaranteed or System-Specific?

The ANSI SQL 2003 standard indicates a general left-to-right evaluation order for WHERE clause expressions. However, it explicitly states that the actual evaluation order is implementation-dependent. Each Database Management System (DBMS) has its own optimization strategies for boolean expression evaluation.

DBMS-Specific Behavior

Different database systems handle this differently:

• SQL Server: Typically evaluates left-to-right, but the query optimizer might rearrange expressions for efficiency.
• Oracle: Generally supports short-circuiting, but the precise evaluation sequence can vary.
• MySQL: Short-circuiting isn't guaranteed; evaluation usually follows a left-to-right pattern.

Illustrative Example

Consider this WHERE clause:

SELECT * 
FROM Table t 
WHERE @key IS NULL OR (@key IS NOT NULL AND @key = t.Key)

If @key is NULL, the first condition (@key IS NULL) is true. The ANSI standard leaves the evaluation of the second condition (@key IS NOT NULL AND @key = t.Key) up to the DBMS.

• Left-to-right evaluation would skip the second condition.
• A DBMS might optimize and avoid evaluating the second condition regardless of the evaluation order.

Conclusion: The presence and behavior of short-circuiting in SQL WHERE clauses are not standardized. Relying on it for correctness is risky. Developers must consult their specific DBMS documentation and conduct empirical testing to determine the actual evaluation behavior.

The above is the detailed content of Does SQL's WHERE Clause Guarantee Short-Circuit Evaluation?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!