Member Initializer Lists vs. Constructor Assignments: When Does It Matter?

Member Initializer Lists vs. Constructor Assignments: A Deeper Dive

In C , it is often debated whether there is a significant difference between using a member initializer list and assigning values in a constructor. While both approaches achieve the same end result, there are subtle distinctions that may be important in specific cases.

Member Initializer List: A Glance

A member initializer list is a comma-separated list of member names and their initial values, enclosed in curly braces and placed at the beginning of a constructor. For instance:

class MyClass {
private:
    int _capacity;
    int* _data;
    int _len;

public:
    MyClass(): _capacity(15), _data(NULL), _len(0) {}
};

Here, the constructor initializes all three member variables in the member initializer list.

Assignments in Constructor: A Different Approach

Alternatively, one can assign values to members within the constructor body, as seen here:

class MyClass {
private:
    int _capacity;
    int* _data;
    int _len;

public:
    MyClass() {
        _capacity = 15;
        _data = NULL;
        _len = 0;
    }
};

In this case, the constructor initializes members using individual statements.

The Internal Perspective: Code Generation

When compiled, both approaches ultimately result in the same machine code. The compiler generates code to assign values to member variables in both cases, regardless of whether an initializer list is used.

Key Differences: When Initialization Matters

While functionally equivalent, member initializer lists and constructor assignments differ primarily in circumstances where initializing members presents specific requirements:

• Constant Members: When initializing constant members (declared with const), a member initializer list is mandatory, as it ensures immediate initialization.
• References: References must be initialized in the initializer list.
• Base Class Parameters: When a base class constructor requires parameters, they should be passed through the initializer list.

Conclusion

While member initializer lists and constructor assignments may seem interchangeable, their distinction lies in specific scenarios where exact initialization order or immutability (constant members) is crucial. In such cases, member initializer lists provide a clear and reliable mechanism for initializing members.

The above is the detailed content of Member Initializer Lists vs. Constructor Assignments: When Does It Matter?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!