MySQL or PHP: Where Should Database Calculations Be Performed?

MySQL vs. PHP: Where to Perform Calculations

In the realm of database-driven applications, the question arises whether to perform calculations in MySQL or PHP. While some developers prefer to keep all logic in PHP, others opt for a hybrid approach, balancing speed and maintainability.

Maintainability vs. Speed

Proponents of keeping calculations in PHP argue for maintainability, claiming that it centralizes code and makes it easier to understand and modify. However, those who advocate for MySQL calculations prioritize speed, citing the database's optimized performance for certain operations.

Finding a Balance

Striking a balance between maintainability and speed involves playing to the strengths of each system. Aggregating, joining, and filtering are best performed in MySQL, minimizing data transfer and leveraging its optimization. On the other hand, date formatting, string manipulation, and individual value handling are more efficiently done in PHP.

Specific Examples

• Date Range Selection: Retrieving users created in the last 24 hours should be executed in MySQL using NOW() - 1 day.
• Capitalizing Names: PHP is more suitable for tasks like capitalizing first and last names, due to its flexibility in handling name formats.
• String Concatenation: Concatenation is generally better done in PHP, especially when combined values may vary in length or format.

Rules of Thumb

• Incremental ID generation: MySQL
• Default value application: MySQL
• Record reduction: MySQL
• Dataset size reduction: MySQL
• Ordering, aggregation, sub-queries, and joins: MySQL
• Triggers: Explore carefully

Conclusion

Ultimately, the decision of where to perform calculations depends on the specific application and its requirements. While maintainability is crucial, premature optimization should be avoided, and the balance between speed and code clarity must be carefully considered.

The above is the detailed content of MySQL or PHP: Where Should Database Calculations Be Performed?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!