在 JavaScript 生態系統中,選擇 npm 與 YARN 作為套件管理器可以顯著影響您的開發工作流程。 npm 和yarn 都是廣泛使用的工具,可協助開發人員管理專案中的依賴項,但每種工具都提供獨特的功能來滿足不同的專案需求。 npm 與yarn 的深入比較涵蓋了它們的主要差異、優勢和用例,可協助您為專案做出明智的決策。
1. 安裝及依賴解析
新專案管理
npm 按順序安裝依賴項並在 node_modules 資料夾中建立巢狀結構,這可能會導致安裝時間更長並可能導致依賴項重複。看起來像這樣:
project/ ├── node_modules/ │ ├── package-a/ │ │ └── node_modules/ │ │ └── package-b/ │ └── package-c/
優點:
- 熟悉程度: npm 預先安裝了 Node.js,使其成為許多開發人員的預設套件管理器。
- 廣泛的兼容性: 透過 npm 龐大的生態系統,大多數 JavaScript 專案無需額外設定即可無縫運作。
缺點:
- 效能:順序安裝可能會導致安裝速度變慢,尤其是對於大型專案。
- 巢狀依賴項:依賴項的深度巢狀可能會導致 node_modules 資料夾臃腫,有時會導致限制目錄深度的檔案系統問題。
紗
Yarn 透過使用並行安裝改進了 npm 的安裝過程,從而創建了扁平結構:
project/ ├── node_modules/ │ ├── package-a/ │ ├── package-b/ │ └── package-c/
優點:
- 速度: Yarn 的平行安裝通常比 npm 快 2-3 倍,這對於具有許多依賴項的專案來說非常有效率。
- 扁平結構:扁平資料夾結構可防止深層巢狀問題,並最大限度地降低依賴衝突的風險。
缺點:
- 額外設定: Yarn 需要與 Node.js 分開安裝,這為新使用者增加了額外的步驟。
- 小型項目的開銷:對於小型項目,yarn 的效能提升可能不那麼明顯,這使得 npm 成為更簡單的選擇。
2. 鎖定檔案和確定性構建
npm:package-lock.json
npm 使用 package-lock.json 檔案來鎖定依賴版本,確保跨環境安裝一致:
{ "name": "project", "version": "1.0.0", "dependencies": { "lodash": "^4.17.21" } }
優點:
- 自動生成: package-lock.json 檔案自動生成,有助於確保在所有環境中安裝相同版本的依賴項。
- 向後相容性: 確保較舊的 npm 版本仍然可以正常運行,保持相容性。
缺點:
- 使用不一致(舊版):在舊版的 npm 中,預設並非總是使用 package-lock.json 文件,這可能會導致安裝不一致。
紗線:紗線.lock
Yarn 的yarn.lock 具有相同的用途,但始終預設產生並使用,以確保更具確定性的建置:
# yarn lockfile v1 lodash@^4.17.21: version "4.17.21" resolved "https://registry.yarnpkg.com/lodash/-/lodash-4.17.21.tgz" integrity sha512-v2kDEe57lec...
優點:
- 預設確定性: Yarn 的yarn.lock 檔案保證在所有環境中安裝一致。
- 總是使用: 與 npm 不同,yarn.lock 檔案始終被使用,確保每次安裝都是相同的。
缺點:
- 簡單專案的開銷: 鎖定檔案的嚴格性可能感覺像是較小或不太複雜的專案的開銷。
3. 安全特性
新專案管理
npm 提供了一個內建的 npm 審計命令,透過掃描 npm 安全諮詢資料庫來檢查專案依賴項中的漏洞:
npm audit
Pros:
- Easily Accessible: The audit feature is integrated into npm, offering developers a quick way to check for security issues.
- Large Database: npm has a vast security advisory database due to its large user base, covering many known vulnerabilities.
Cons:
- Less Detailed Reports: The npm audit command may not provide as detailed or actionable feedback as developers expect.
yarn
Yarn also has an audit command but goes further by verifying package integrity during installation. Yarn 2+ introduced "Zero-Installs," allowing projects to skip installs entirely, reducing the risk of security issues when fetching dependencies.
yarn audit
Pros:
- More Proactive: Yarn not only checks for known vulnerabilities but also validates the integrity of every package during installation.
- Zero-Installs: This feature adds another layer of security by enabling projects to be cloned and used without running yarn install, reducing potential risks.
Cons:
- Setup Complexity: For Yarn’s more advanced security features like Zero-Installs, developers need to adopt Yarn 2+, which can require additional setup and configuration.
4. Workspaces and Monorepo Support
npm Workspaces
npm introduced workspaces in version 7, allowing developers to manage multiple packages within the same project. This feature is particularly useful in monorepos, where several related packages are maintained together.
{ "name": "my-project", "workspaces": [ "packages/*" ] }
Pros:
- Official Support: npm’s native workspace support simplifies dependency management in monorepos.
- Familiarity: npm workspaces follow the same conventions as other npm functionality, so it’s easy to integrate into existing workflows.
Cons:
- Newer Feature: npm’s workspace implementation is relatively new and may not be as fully-featured as yarn’s.
yarn Workspaces
Yarn has supported workspaces for much longer and is generally considered more feature-rich for handling monorepos. Yarn’s workspace feature allows for more granular control over dependencies in monorepos.
{ "private": true, "workspaces": [ "packages/*" ] }
Pros:
- Mature Feature: Yarn’s workspaces are more robust and offer additional commands for managing multiple packages.
- Better for Large Monorepos: Yarn is generally considered the better choice for larger or more complex monorepos due to its mature implementation.
Cons:
- Learning Curve: For developers new to monorepos or Yarn’s workspace management, there may be a steeper learning curve.
5. CLI Commands and Usability
npm
npm offers a variety of commands for managing dependencies:
npm install <package> npm uninstall <package> npm update npm run <script> </script></package></package>
Pros:
- Consistency: As the default package manager for Node.js, npm’s commands are familiar and widely used.
- Extensive Documentation: npm's extensive community and documentation make it easier for developers to find solutions to common issues.
Cons:
-
Verbosity: npm commands can be more verbose and less intuitive compared to yarn. For example, npm install
versus yarn’s simpler yarn add . - Fewer Utility Commands: While npm covers the basics, it lacks some of the utility commands yarn provides, such as yarn why for checking package dependencies.
yarn
Yarn offers similar commands but with shorter and more intuitive syntax:
yarn add <package> yarn remove <package> yarn upgrade yarn <script> </script></package></package>
Pros:
- Simplicity: Yarn commands are often shorter and more intuitive. For example, yarn replaces npm install, and yarn <script> replaces npm run <script>.</script>
- Additional Features: Yarn provides extra utility commands like yarn why, which shows why a package was installed and which dependencies rely on it.
Cons:
- Learning Curve: Developers accustomed to npm might find the transition to yarn’s command set slightly confusing at first, particularly with yarn-specific commands.
- Less Ubiquity: While yarn has many useful features, it’s not as universally used as npm, meaning there may be fewer resources or support in certain cases.
6. Offline Mode and Caching
npm
npm has basic offline capabilities, allowing you to install packages from the cache if they were previously installed:
npm install --offline
Pros:
- Improved Offline Support: Recent versions of npm have made improvements to offline support, but it's still limited.
Cons:
- Less Reliable: npm’s offline capabilities aren’t as comprehensive as yarn’s, especially in environments with limited internet access.
yarn
Yarn’s offline support is more robust, allowing you to work completely offline as long as the dependencies have been previously installed.
yarn install --offline
Pros:
- Reliable Offline Mode: Yarn stores a more comprehensive cache, ensuring that all necessary files are available when offline.
- Ideal for CI/CD: Yarn’s offline capabilities significantly improve CI/CD pipeline performance by reducing the need for internet access.
Cons:
- Initial Setup: Yarn’s offline support requires an initial installation before it can fully function offline.
Conclusion: npm vs yarn
In summary, the choice between npm vs yarn comes down to the needs of your project:
- npm is the default and most familiar option. It’s well-suited for small to medium projects and offers solid features like npm audit and workspace support. If your project is relatively simple, npm is likely sufficient for your needs.
- yarn shines in larger projects or complex monorepos where speed, deterministic installs, and robust offline support are crucial. Yarn’s parallel installation, enhanced security features, and advanced workspace management make it the better choice for teams working on large-scale projects.
When comparing npm vs yarn, consider your project’s size, complexity, and need for features like workspaces and offline support. Both are excellent tools, but your decision should align with your workflow and project requirements.
以上是npm 與yarn:主要差異與深入比較的詳細內容。更多資訊請關注PHP中文網其他相關文章!

JavaScript字符串替換方法詳解及常見問題解答 本文將探討兩種在JavaScript中替換字符串字符的方法:在JavaScript代碼內部替換和在網頁HTML內部替換。 在JavaScript代碼內部替換字符串 最直接的方法是使用replace()方法: str = str.replace("find","replace"); 該方法僅替換第一個匹配項。要替換所有匹配項,需使用正則表達式並添加全局標誌g: str = str.replace(/fi

本教程向您展示瞭如何將自定義的Google搜索API集成到您的博客或網站中,提供了比標準WordPress主題搜索功能更精緻的搜索體驗。 令人驚訝的是簡單!您將能夠將搜索限制為Y

因此,在這裡,您準備好了解所有稱為Ajax的東西。但是,到底是什麼? AJAX一詞是指用於創建動態,交互式Web內容的一系列寬鬆的技術。 Ajax一詞,最初由Jesse J創造

本文系列在2017年中期進行了最新信息和新示例。 在此JSON示例中,我們將研究如何使用JSON格式將簡單值存儲在文件中。 使用鍵值對符號,我們可以存儲任何類型的

增強您的代碼演示文稿:10個語法熒光筆針對開發人員在您的網站或博客上共享代碼段的開發人員是開發人員的常見實踐。 選擇合適的語法熒光筆可以顯著提高可讀性和視覺吸引力。 t

利用輕鬆的網頁佈局:8 ESTISSEL插件jQuery大大簡化了網頁佈局。 本文重點介紹了簡化該過程的八個功能強大的JQuery插件,對於手動網站創建特別有用

本文介紹了關於JavaScript和JQuery模型視圖控制器(MVC)框架的10多個教程的精選選擇,非常適合在新的一年中提高您的網絡開發技能。 這些教程涵蓋了來自Foundatio的一系列主題

核心要點 JavaScript 中的 this 通常指代“擁有”該方法的對象,但具體取決於函數的調用方式。 沒有當前對象時,this 指代全局對象。在 Web 瀏覽器中,它由 window 表示。 調用函數時,this 保持全局對象;但調用對象構造函數或其任何方法時,this 指代對象的實例。 可以使用 call()、apply() 和 bind() 等方法更改 this 的上下文。這些方法使用給定的 this 值和參數調用函數。 JavaScript 是一門優秀的編程語言。幾年前,這句話可


熱AI工具

Undresser.AI Undress
人工智慧驅動的應用程序,用於創建逼真的裸體照片

AI Clothes Remover
用於從照片中去除衣服的線上人工智慧工具。

Undress AI Tool
免費脫衣圖片

Clothoff.io
AI脫衣器

AI Hentai Generator
免費產生 AI 無盡。

熱門文章

熱工具

MantisBT
Mantis是一個易於部署的基於Web的缺陷追蹤工具,用於幫助產品缺陷追蹤。它需要PHP、MySQL和一個Web伺服器。請查看我們的演示和託管服務。

DVWA
Damn Vulnerable Web App (DVWA) 是一個PHP/MySQL的Web應用程序,非常容易受到攻擊。它的主要目標是成為安全專業人員在合法環境中測試自己的技能和工具的輔助工具,幫助Web開發人員更好地理解保護網路應用程式的過程,並幫助教師/學生在課堂環境中教授/學習Web應用程式安全性。 DVWA的目標是透過簡單直接的介面練習一些最常見的Web漏洞,難度各不相同。請注意,該軟體中

SublimeText3 英文版
推薦:為Win版本,支援程式碼提示!

SAP NetWeaver Server Adapter for Eclipse
將Eclipse與SAP NetWeaver應用伺服器整合。

Dreamweaver Mac版
視覺化網頁開發工具