Comparison of responsive websites and adaptive websites: Which one should I choose for a mobile site?

What are responsive websites and adaptive websites?

Adaptive website (adaptive website) Response Do not adjust the position of web page elements when the width of the browser changes, scale web page elements to Adapt within available space.

Responsive website Responds to changes in browser width by adjusting the position of web page elements to fit within the available space .

PS: I really don’t know why many people confuse adaptive websites with responsive websites. (Adaptive website! = Responsive website)

Comparison between responsive website and adaptive website:

Development Difficulty Comparison

Adaptive website development is both complex (adaptation control for different screens) and simple (independent of PC), but easy to maintain and debug (only mobile end-side processing events).

Responsive websites are relatively simple to develop (just adjust through media queries) and complex (highly coupled with PC web page elements), but are not easy to debug and maintain (binding mobile terminals and mobile phones) end-side processing events).

Page performance comparison

The adaptive website only has the layout and style of the mobile terminal (less content), It is downloaded to the browser and displayed immediately, so the performance is fast.

Responsive websites not only have the layout and style of mobile terminals, but also the layout and style of PC (with a lot of content). After downloading to the browser, the web page layout is adjusted and then displayed, so the performance is slow.

PS: Responsive websites also have ways to improve performance, which is to load different media query styles for the screen and selectively load resources. But the performance is still not as good as adaptive websites.

User experience comparison

The responsive website ensures consistency between the PC and mobile terminals, with a fluid layout.

The adaptive website ensures a more mobile-friendly experience.

SEO Comparison

Adaptive websites are not easy to aggregate website weight, but they can aggregate weight through redirection.

Responsive websites are easy to gather website weight, and it is easy to add the weight of the mobile side to the weight of the PC side to improve the website ranking.

PS: This approach is to use separate URLs for the computer and mobile terminals.

Which is better, a responsive website or an adaptive website? Which one to choose?

# It is recommended to develop adaptive websites to pursue performance and user experience. (Most Internet companies separate the web PC side and the mobile side)

Responsive websites are not suitable for developing some more complex websites website. (Involving some animated interactive effects, too many page elements)

#It is recommended to develop a responsive computer website (transition to tablet, not mobile) And develop a set of responsive mobile website (transition to the size below tablet version, not transition to tablet version)

The above is the detailed content of Comparison of responsive websites and adaptive websites: Which one should I choose for a mobile site?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!