Web Reference or Service Reference: Which Should I Choose for My C# Project?

Web Reference vs. Service Reference: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction

Many developers face confusion when choosing between Web Reference and Service Reference when working with WSDLs in C#. To clarify these concepts, let's delve into the differences and their implications.

Web Reference vs. Service Reference

Web Reference is the legacy approach for adding a web service reference in ASP.NET (ASMX) technology. It uses the XmlSerializer for data exchange and produces an ASMX client for an ASMX web service. This method is available in various project types, including console applications and Windows forms.

In contrast, Service Reference is the modern approach for adding a WCF service reference. It provides a more advanced and flexible service model compared to Web Reference. This method is primarily used with WCF services, but it can be employed in .NET 3.5 projects without WCF as well.

Configuration Options

When adding a Service Reference, you can click on the "Advanced" button to access additional configuration options. Here, you can select "Add Web Reference" to use the legacy method instead.

Implications for .NET 3.5

If your project is based on .NET 3.5 and you're not prepared to move to WCF, you can still use the old-style Web Reference by selecting the appropriate option in the "Advanced" configuration dialog. However, this approach will result in a less capable service model compared to Service Reference.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between Web Reference and Service Reference is crucial for selecting the appropriate approach based on the project requirements and the version of .NET being used. For projects using .NET 3.5 that do not require WCF's advanced features, Web Reference can still be employed. However, if you're working with WCF services or prefer a more modern and flexible service model, Service Reference is the recommended choice.

The above is the detailed content of Web Reference or Service Reference: Which Should I Choose for My C# Project?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!