Is Python's Lack of Private Variables a Cultural Norm or a Sound Programming Practice?

Python's Private Variables: Cultural Norm or Programming Best Practice?

In Java, managing class variables' accessibility with private, public, and protected modifiers ensures data encapsulation and prevents unauthorized modification. However, Python seems to defy this convention, and Bruce Eckels' insights in "Python 3 Patterns, Recipes and Idioms" raise questions about the necessity of such modifiers.

Eckels states that Python classes automatically create instance variables within the constructor, leaving developers free to access them openly. This raises concerns as external code could potentially alter these variables, hindering data integrity.

To address these concerns, Python culture dictates that programmers refrain from editing variables belonging to other classes. Such a norm encourages responsible programming and reinforces the notion that external code should not interfere with internal class functionality.

Despite this cultural practice, Python's naming conventions provide a workaround for emulating private variables. PEP 8 recommends using a double underscore prefix (__foo) to mark variables as inaccessible to code outside the containing namespace. While this naming mechanism does not enforce true privacy, it serves as a strong convention discouraging external variable manipulation.

Additionally, the single underscore prefix (_bar) signifies that a variable should be for internal use within the class or module. While it doesn't prevent external access, this convention signals that such variables should remain untouched.

In summary, the absence of true private variables in Python forces adherence to programming best practices and responsible code maintenance. By respecting class boundaries and using appropriate naming conventions, Python programmers ensure the integrity of code and promote clean, maintainable software.

The above is the detailed content of Is Python's Lack of Private Variables a Cultural Norm or a Sound Programming Practice?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!