Selenium `.text` vs. `.get_attribute('innerHTML')`: When Should I Use Each?

Understanding the Distinction between .text and .get_attribute("innerHTML") in Selenium

Introduction

When interacting with web elements using Selenium, obtaining their textual content can be achieved through different approaches. Among these are .text and .get_attribute("innerHTML"). While they may seem interchangeable, there are fundamental differences between the two and specific instances when one is more appropriate than the other.

.get_attribute("innerHTML")

.get_attribute("innerHTML") retrieves the innerHTML of an element, including all its content and markup. This method attempts to fetch the property with the specified name first. If no property exists, it returns the attribute with the same name. If neither is found, it returns None.

Values deemed truthy (equivalent to true or false) are rendered as booleans. Conversely, all other non-None values are returned as strings. For attributes or properties that do not exist, None is returned.

Arguments:

• innerHTML: The name of the attribute/property to extract.

Example:

# Get the innerHTML of an element
html = target_element.get_attribute("innerHTML")

.text

.text retrieves the text content of an element, excluding any markup or styling.

Definition:

def text(self):
    """The text of the element."""
    return self._execute(Command.GET_ELEMENT_TEXT)['value']

Example:

# Get the text of an element
text = target_element.text

Differences and When to Use Each Method

Despite the superficial similarity of .text and .get_attribute("innerHTML"), there are crucial distinctions to consider:

• Data Type: .text returns a string, while .get_attribute("innerHTML") returns a combination of strings and markup as HTML.
• Content: .text only captures the visible text within an element, while .get_attribute("innerHTML") includes all elements and styles nested within.
• Attribute vs. Property: .text accesses a property, while .get_attribute("innerHTML") can retrieve either an attribute or property. In case of standard attributes, .text provides a shortcut access to its underlying property.

Properties vs. Attributes in HTML

When loading a web page, the browser interprets the HTML and creates DOM objects. Attributes defined in the HTML code become properties of these DOM objects. However, if an attribute is not standard for a particular element, it will not have a corresponding property.

In such cases, attributes can be accessed using the following methods:

• elem.hasAttribute(name): Checks for the presence of an attribute.
• elem.getAttribute(name): Retrieves the value of an attribute.
• elem.setAttribute(name, value): Sets the value of an attribute.
• elem.removeAttribute(name): Removes an attribute.

Property-Attribute Synchronization

Standard attributes in HTML are usually synchronized with their corresponding properties. This means that when an attribute is modified, the property is automatically updated, and vice versa.

Python Attributes and Properties

In Python, an attribute is accessed using the dot notation (e.g., someObj.name). It can either be an instance variable or accessed through specialized getter and setter methods defined as properties.

Conclusion

Choosing between .text and .get_attribute("innerHTML") when extracting element content depends on the specific requirements of the automation task. If the goal is to obtain the visible text without any markup or styles, .text is ideal. Alternatively, if a complete representation of the HTML content is needed, including all elements and their formatting, .get_attribute("innerHTML") is the appropriate choice.

The above is the detailed content of Selenium `.text` vs. `.get_attribute('innerHTML')`: When Should I Use Each?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!