Why Does Using `good()` or `!eof()` Read the Last Line of a File Twice?

Testing Stream Condition: Why Using good() or !eof() Reads the Last Line Twice

When attempting to read a text file line by line using ifstream, utilizing f.good() or !f.eof() within a loop can result in reading the last line twice. Let's delve into the reason behind this behavior and explore alternative solutions.

Understanding Stream State Functions

good(), eof(), and fail() are stream state functions that indicate the current state of the input stream. However, they do not predict the success or failure of future input operations.

Reason for Reading the Last Line Twice

The problem occurs because good() and eof() do not necessarily reflect the outcome of the last input operation. For instance, !f.eof() does not guarantee that the previous getline() was successful. Conversely, not being at EOF does not imply that the last input operation failed.

Alternative Solution: Checking Stream State after Input Operation

To correctly read and process lines, it's crucial to check the stream state after performing the input operation:

if (getline(f, line)) {
  // Use line here
} else {
  // Handle error or end of file
}

Alternative Solution: Iterating with Loop

Another elegant solution is to use a loop that iterates until getline() fails:

for (string line; getline(f, line);) {
  // Use line here
}

Avoiding Misnamed good() Function

Finally, it's important to note that good() is a misnomer and is not equivalent to testing the stream itself. It's recommended to use the techniques described above instead of relying on good().

The above is the detailed content of Why Does Using `good()` or `!eof()` Read the Last Line of a File Twice?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!