Why Does C Allow Trailing Commas in Initializer Lists?

Trailing Commas in Initializer Lists

While it may seem intuitive for a trailing comma in an initializer list to be a syntax error, the C standard explicitly permits it. Understanding the reasons behind this allowance enhances our comprehension of C syntax.

The grammar rules outlined in 8.5.1 allow for an additional comma at the end of an initializer list. Unlike in function-call argument lists, which prohibit redundant commas at the end, initializer lists have this explicit exception.

This allowance exists for practical reasons related to code generation and extensibility. By allowing trailing commas, it becomes easier to generate source code programmatically. Consider adding an entry to an initializer list: with a trailing comma, only one new line needs to be added, simplifying the process.

Furthermore, it becomes simpler to extend or modify code with trailing commas. Without them, adding or removing an entry would require adjusting commas, which could lead to errors. Trailing commas eliminate this issue, ensuring uniformity in line handling.

Moreover, code generation is made easier with trailing commas. For example, a pseudo-code generator could easily iterate through items and output each one with a comma delimiter, regardless of whether it is the first or last item.

The above is the detailed content of Why Does C Allow Trailing Commas in Initializer Lists?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!