Why Were Designated Initializers Absent from C 11?

Designated Initializers in C : Why the Absence in C 11

The omission of designated initializers in C 11 remains an intriguing question for many programmers. In C99, the designated initializer syntax, such as .age = 18, allows for convenient initialization of specific members of a struct. However, this feature is notably absent from C 11.

Rationale for Exclusion

The C 11 standard committee has repeatedly declined proposals for designated initializers. Their rationale stems from several inherent complexities:

Indeterminate Execution Order:
C99 lacks specific rules for evaluating designated initializer expressions. The order in which evaluations occur is indeterminate, potentially leading to inconsistencies in program behavior. In contrast, C enforces a strict order of initializer-clause evaluation.

Compatibility Issues:
Implementing designated initializers in C would have required breaking compatibility with existing C99 implementations. This would have introduced inconsistencies and potential errors for migrating code.

Nesting and Array Restrictions:
C99 allows nesting of designated initializers and designated initialization of arrays. These features proved challenging to incorporate into C without compromising language consistency.

C99 Standards Clash:
Designated initializers in C99 also allow for member initialization without specifying all members. This contrasts with C 's requirement that all or none of a struct's members must be initialized using designators.

Limited Support in C 20

In response to industry demand, the C committee has since introduced limited support for designated initializers in C 20. However, this implementation imposes restrictions that address the concerns mentioned above. Designated initializers must be used in strict declaration order, nesting and array initialization are not supported, and all or none of a struct's members must be initialized with designators.

Alternatives

Despite the lack of C99-style designated initializers, C provides alternative methods for initializing class members:

• Constructor Initialization: Allows for explicit member initialization within the class definition.
• Member Initialization List: Enables member initialization directly within the constructor.
• Aggregate Initialization: Similar to designated initialization, but applied to aggregate types (e.g., structs).

The above is the detailed content of Why Were Designated Initializers Absent from C 11?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!