Why Does C Use the Scope Resolution Operator (::) While Java Only Uses the Dot Operator (.)?

The Necessity of the Scope Resolution Operator in C

Unlike Java, which relies solely on the dot operator (.) for member access, C employs the scope resolution operator (::) to serve a unique purpose. Understanding the reasons behind this distinction is crucial for grasping the intricacies of C syntax.

One compelling reason for using :: in C lies in its ability to disambiguate between similar identifiers. Consider the following code:

struct foo
{
  int blah;
};

struct thingy
{
  int data;
};

struct bar : public foo
{
  thingy foo;
};

In this scenario, both the struct bar and the member variable of bar are named foo. To resolve this ambiguity, C uses :: to identify the typename (e.g., bar::foo) while reserving . for member access (e.g., test.foo).

Moreover, :: possesses a higher precedence than .., which enables expressions like the following to be parsed correctly:

a.b::c;
// Evaluated as a.(b::c)

This precedence rule ensures that the expression is interpreted as accessing the member c of the class b (nested within a), rather than interpreting it as accessing the member b of the class a.

Ultimately, the inclusion of :: in C stems from the decision to allow nested classes with the same name as their members. This feature, though perplexing at first, provides programmers with greater flexibility in naming conventions.

The above is the detailed content of Why Does C Use the Scope Resolution Operator (::) While Java Only Uses the Dot Operator (.)?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!