Default Values for Function Parameters: Should They Be Declared in the Header or the Definition?

Default Values for Function Parameters: Understanding the Standard

When declaring functions in C , developers can specify default values for parameters. This raises the question of which approach is the accepted standard and the underlying reasons behind it.

There are two primary ways to declare functions with default parameters:

1. Declaration in the Function Definition Only:

<code class="cpp">int Add(int a, int b);
int Add(int a, int b = 3)
{

}</code>

2. Declaration in the Function Header:

<code class="cpp">int Add(int a, int b = 3);
int Add(int a, int b)
{

}</code>

While both approaches may compile successfully, the standard recommends placing the default parameter declaration in the function header. This practice ensures early binding and prevents potential compilation errors.

Specifically, if the function declaration and definition are separated into different files (e.g., a header file and a source file), placing the default parameter declaration in the header is crucial. This is because the compilation process for any file using the header will not see the default parameter declaration if it is only specified in the definition. Consequently, any attempt to use the default parameter without explicitly providing it will result in a compilation error.

To illustrate this, consider the following example:

<code class="cpp">// lib.h
int Add(int a, int b);</code>

<code class="cpp">// lib.cpp
int Add(int a, int b = 3) {
   ...
}</code>

<code class="cpp">// test.cpp
#include "lib.h"

int main() {
    Add(4); // Error: default parameter not declared in the header file
}</code>

In this scenario, the compilation of test.cpp will fail because the default parameter declaration is not visible in the header file.

Therefore, to avoid such errors, the standard practice is to declare default parameters in the function header. By doing so, the compiler is aware of the default values during the early binding process, ensuring successful code compilation during linking.

The above is the detailed content of Default Values for Function Parameters: Should They Be Declared in the Header or the Definition?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!