Why Does -1 % 2 Return -1 in Java, but 1 in Python?

Modulo Operations in Java: Why Positive and Negative Numbers Matter

When performing modulo operations in Java, understanding the subtle difference between the modulus and the remainder is crucial. Unlike Python, Java's modulo operator (%) computes the remainder, not the modulus.

Consider the example provided in the question: -1 % 2 in Java returns -1, while in Python, it returns 1. This is because Python calculates the modulus, which always yields a non-negative value, while Java calculates the remainder, which preserves the sign of the first operand (-1 in this case).

To obtain the same behavior as Python, you can employ the following techniques:

• Addition and modulo: Add 2 to the negative result and then apply the modulo again. This operation ensures that the result is always positive:

<code class="java">int i = (((-1 % 2) + 2) % 2)</code>

• Conditional increment: Initialize the result to the original remainder, and if it's negative, add 2:

<code class="java">int i = -1 % 2;
if (i <p>Remember, these techniques apply whenever you need to compute the modulus of negative numbers in Java. While the operators in Python and Java may have the same symbol (%), they behave differently, leading to potential confusion if you're transitioning between languages.</p></code>

The above is the detailed content of Why Does -1 % 2 Return -1 in Java, but 1 in Python?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!